You are currently logged-out. You can log-in or create an account to see more talks, save favorites, and more.
Ethics, Impermanence, and Zen Practice
AI Suggested Keywords:
Seminar_Continuity_to_Continuum
This seminar addresses the tension between professional duties and ethical integrity, illustrated by past experiences with governmental projects, and explores the implications of ethical compromise. It underscores the importance of recognizing impermanence as central to Zen practice, emphasizing the development of mindfulness and structured consciousness. Initial practices for newcomers include mindfulness of actions and breath, regular zazen, engagement with teachings like the Eightfold Path, and active participation in Sangha and mentorship sessions, as foundational steps in embracing the non-substantiality of self.
Referenced Concepts and Teachings:
-
Five Skandhas: Explored to help practitioners understand that consciousness has a structure and to recognize how the mind participates in creating the perception of the world, leading to insights into the insubstantiality of self.
-
The Eightfold Path: Emphasized as a key framework for guiding attention toward beneficial conduct and cultivating mindfulness, including components like right speech and right livelihood.
-
Impermanence and Non-Self: Highlighted as crucial realizations in progressing beyond the habit of perceiving permanence, underscoring the difficulty yet transformative potential of integrating these insights into practice.
-
Koan Practice ("The one who is not busy"): Suggested for aiding in the development of a "background mind," fostering awareness even amid activity, and illustrating the non-dual nature of stillness and action in Zen practice.
AI Suggested Title: Ethics, Impermanence, and Zen Practice
...on ships or working in warehouses and things like that. But then maybe it was okay to work for a university. I thought that would be probably a fairly pure place to work. So I worked for this... you know, trying to develop programs for public education, adult education. So I had to face big compromises and small compromises, much to my surprise. The big compromise I wouldn't go along with, this department handled a very large amount of money from the federal government to get architects and engineers to build bomb shelters.
[01:20]
in their buildings. Dass diese Abteilung einen ziemlich großen Geldbetrag vom Staat bekam, um Bomben-Schutzbunker zu bauen. The bomb shelters for who? For people. Oh, just generally. Not for bombs. Yeah. Not for the government people? I just didn't get it. Yeah, during the... I'm just kidding. During the 60s, you know, there was always this threat, well, Russia might bomb us. And... So the government tried to have architects and engineers build bomb shelters into all new buildings. Sorry.
[02:22]
Yeah, I'm sorry to drive some people out to cook for us. I'll finish in a minute. So I... First, it was obvious to me that these bomb shelters would not protect you from an atomic bomb or hydrogen bomb. So it was also obvious to me the real purpose of this was a psychological preparation for war. So I went to Suzuki Roshi and he said, oh yes, Japan did similar things to prepare Japan to go to war. So I took a stand in this department, which was 35 or so employees. And I was assistant head of the department.
[03:53]
that I would not handle any piece of paper having to do with this program. So it all had to be routed around me. It couldn't go through my office. And I was willing to lose my job order. I had a little baby and a wife, so it would have been something to lose my job. But they didn't fire me. So I felt very moral and good, you know. Or at least I felt I could take a position, right? But then my boss got involved with complicated political things and he expected me to write letters, backdated letters.
[05:15]
And if I'd refused to backdate the letters, I definitely would have been fired. In other words, you're pretending the letter was written in July when it actually was written in August, you know. So I did that, but it didn't make me feel good. Then I knew this guy who was the public relations director for the company that developed the first birth control pill. And I don't want to tell you the whole story, but basically there was a guy who was advisor to the company who I knew was doing something wrong.
[06:25]
to this company that developed the birth control pill. And he was part of a real high medical family in America. His brother was the advisor to the U.S. president at the time and stuff. And this guy was a real creep. creep, a dishonest, slimy sloth. But somehow my boss was going to go to work for him because of this political stuff.
[07:39]
And even though he had me back to the letters, I tried to help him by telling him, look, I know something about this guy, you better not work for him. And even though I helped him to return these letters to the animals, I told him, I know something about this guy, you don't work better for him. But my boss phoned him right away and said, oh, I know this about you, and it came from so-and-so. It came from me. Well, immediately my friend, who was public relations director for the company, public information was fired. And this guy called me up for half an hour talking about how he's going to destroy me. You know, I mean, it was unbelievable, the venom from this guy. This was my first venture into the workaday world.
[09:04]
So I went to lawyers and things like that, tried to figure out what could happen. But I suppose I'm saying that when you work in even a good situation like a university... You can find yourself in extremely compromising situations. How can you be honest sometimes? How do you try to help somebody here? So this experience was quite a strong one for me also to do this. I hope all jobs are not like this. But here was a job, an ideal job for the University of California and
[10:10]
It was really pretty bad. So I think various versions of that happened to a lot of people in their jobs. How do you practice with that? That's also a question I'd like to ask. Okay, let's sit for a moment. Mujojin jemiyo no wa yakusen mano ni wo ayo koto katashi
[13:35]
Vajravasthinman siyujisuru koto etari, negavakuan yoraiyoshin, jitsunyokeshi kate matsuran, One undetroffener, durchdringender und vollkommener Dharma findet sich auch in hunderttausend millionen Kalpas musheten. Nur, da ich ihn sehe, in Röhren wahrnehmen und bewahren kann, gelohne ich die Wahrheit des Tathagatas zu erfahren. Hi.
[15:02]
Good morning. So I've recently been feeling that the next prep step for the Dharma Sangha practitioners zuletzt in letzter Zeit habe ich das Gefühl gehabt, dass der nächste Schritt für die Praktizierenden der Dharma Sangha is to break the habit of permanence. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. To develop the habit of of knowing the impermanence of everything. This is fairly easy for me to say.
[16:07]
It's a big, it's a pretty big difficulty to practice it. Es ist eine ziemlich große Schwierigkeit, das zu praktizieren. Yeah, it seems easy. We can do it. At least intellectually we can do it. Es scheint einfach, das zu tun. Zumindest intellektuell können wir das tun. But really to practice it, it's... Yeah. Your practice has to be pretty developed to practice it. And it's a really big, when you do practice it, it's a really big shift in your practice and a big release. Although the awareness of change, of impermanence and so forth is present throughout our practice,
[17:26]
Yeah, present from the beginning. Okay, so, yeah, since I think that, that the next step for us is to break the habit of permanence, of implicit and explicit permanence. So now I have to say, well, here we are with you, each of you, Muss ich jetzt so sagen, ja, jetzt sind wir hier mit jedem von euch? When I've been... Quite a few of you I haven't been practicing with for a long time.
[18:45]
And some of you are quite new to practice. So I think I should try to make up some kind of outline of practice today. And you can help me with the outline. In the afternoon, in our discussion, you can give me some sense of what the stages of practice have been for you. Now what do I mean when I say that the next step for the Dharma Sangha? Well, you know, I observe that I proceed from the feeling that the teachings take hold more fully in our individual practice.
[20:10]
When we're practicing with others with whom the same teachings have taken hold. So I sort of, you know, kind of bumble along. Ich stolpere also da so entlang. Do you know the word bumble? I think I translated it with stumble. It's sort of the same. You can bumble without stumbling. Bumbling is sort of like stumbling. Bumblebee? Bumblebee? They're much, no, they bumble much with much more persistence and accuracy than us. I don't know why, but I think bumblebee is for the sound they make.
[21:24]
It's a different, different, quite, fairly different word. That's good, man. I haven't made a beeline in this teaching, though. I'm bumbling. So I've, for instance, as you well know, I've endlessly taught the five skandhas. So maybe some of you think there's 500 skandhas. But I've done that because I really want a fairly large percentage of you to get the practice.
[22:26]
Ich habe das getan, weil ich möchte, dass ein ziemlich hoher Anteil, ein Prozentsatz von euch die Belehrung wirklich versteht. Yeah, for probably three reasons. Aus wahrscheinlich drei Gründen. One is it makes you aware that consciousness has structure. If you don't get that, there's no adept practice. If you just see what you see and seamlessly see it like a camera, And you don't have any sense that you're structuring what you see. And according to certain you know, habits, rules.
[23:37]
So first of all, even if you don't really practice the five skandhas, I know some of you don't. Yeah, at least you have this intuition now or feeling that yes, consciousness, awareness is structured. Yeah, and then if you actually practice it, you get an ability to... participate in how your mind makes the world. Then you discover more precisely different states of mind than just waking and sleeping. And the occasional lucky zazen period.
[24:45]
Well, that's one reason. Well, that's the second. Das ist also ein Grund, der zweite Grund. The third reason is it gives us, begins to give us the basis to see the insubstantiality of self. Der dritte Grund ist, dass es uns die Grundlage gibt, um to see the insubstantiality of self. Die Nichtsubstantialität des Selbstes zu sehen. To see the habit of me-ness as a habit. Even if an extremely difficult habit to break. Even if me-ness is an extremely difficult habit to break.
[26:02]
Auch wenn dieses Ich, diese Ichheit eine Gewohnheit ist, die äußerst schwer zu brechen ist. In the past, way back a thousand years or two thousand years ago, The schools that were rigorous in saying there's no meanness, substantial meanness, tended to lose popularity. And the schools which snuck in subtle forms of meanness that continued, they gained in popularity. They all used the same words and they sounded sort of the same, but one kind of supported meanness and the other didn't.
[27:05]
Of course, with individual practitioners, we can practice in any way that comes up between us. But still, in the general way I've taught is to try to get a number of people to understand something together. Yeah, and I actually think somehow we've made progress. Mostly because of the good spirit of each of you. That sounds right to me.
[28:38]
So, and mostly the way also, although that's what I've been doing, I've also pretty much let you or supported you in practicing in any way you wanted to. So this will be the first time, I think, that I've actually made some kind of stages, you know. But I think before I leap forward to this Breaking the habit of permanence. So I should step back and look at what are the basics of that leap forward. leap ahead.
[30:09]
So I imagine, if you're new to practice, what ought to be, where should you begin? I think, first of all, you should develop a habit of practicing mindfulness. Primarily of your actions and your breath. Yeah, that's... No, that should be concentrated on. And to help in that, and in addition, it's good if you can develop a daily or weekly practice of zazen.
[31:16]
By weekly I mean daily. three times a week or five times a week or something. And again, as I've always said, just because some zazen is good doesn't mean more zazen is better, more good. In fact, it's... Yeah, you can actually sit too much if you sit on your own several, four, five times a day. That's too much. Yeah. One day a week, maybe it's all right. Because you really want your zazen practice grounded in your daily life. measured by your daily life.
[32:28]
Tested by your daily life. And you shouldn't indefinitely use zazen as a refuge from daily life. You again? You shouldn't use zazen as a refuge from daily life. So you should do zazen in a way in which you are... feel it's... developing presence in your ordinary life, daily life. So, second, it's good to develop a daily or weekly practice of satsang.
[33:35]
Third, it's good to bring some teaching into your life. Like we said yesterday, treat things like your own eyesight. Anyway, some sense of teaching being brought in to your daily life. Often in the form of a phrase or a reminder, etc. Fourth, I would say it would be good to have a general appreciation, awareness of the Eightfold Path. Yeah, you can think of many teachings as kind of targets.
[34:52]
Yeah, like in the four foundations of mindfulness, there's a long tradition of what you bring your attention to. So you bring your attention to a million things. The tradition, ancient tradition, is it's most useful to bring your attention to certain targets. So the Eightfold Path is somewhat the same. Good to bring your attention to your speech, your conduct, livelihood, etc. Yeah, for example.
[36:04]
Okay. And then, if possible, you add a couple more. In this first stage. You try to practice with other members of the Sangha. Yeah, once a week or something. Two or three or five or six of you get together and sit, I don't know. Come here or something. Anyway, you develop some kind of relationship to Sangha practice. And sixth, I guess you develop some relationship, if possible, to a teacher and to a practice center.
[37:05]
So that's what I would call the first stage. And that's fairly easy to bring into your life without changing your life much. But it definitely means you've got to organize your life so that this can be brought into your life. And it should be. And the first stage of practice should be demanding enough that it does require you to order your life to some extent. Okay, that's the first stage. Second stage? Second stage.
[38:29]
Second stage. My goodness. There's seven stages and we're only at... No. Maybe by tomorrow there'll be seven. Okay, the second stage is you develop some kind of... develop a feeling for a background mind. And here it would be good to... Probably practice with the koan, for instance, of which the line comes, the one who is not busy. So developing a background mind, it's quite good to, quite useful to work with the feeling of the one who is not busy. In our busyness, is there simultaneously one who is not busy?
[39:35]
Yeah. I think... Yeah, so we don't... So you don't feel too busy, I should stop now. Yes, we have more time. We can continue. Yes, episode two. Yeah. The mark of Zorro. Zeichen des Zorro? The mark of Zen, excuse me. Zeichen des Zen.
[40:37]
@Transcribed_UNK
@Text_v005
@Score_77.28